Manchester City and Paris Saint-Germain have escaped punishment over alleged breaches of EU competition law following a complaint from Javier Tebas.
Article continues below
Article continues below
Article continues below
Tebas complained about alleged state aidEU Commission not convinced by the evidenceClubs submitted their accounts to claim innocenceFollow GOAL on WhatsApp! 🟢📱WHAT HAPPENED?
La Liga president Tebas launched a formal complaint in July 2023, accusing City and PSG of breaching European Union competition laws. His claims centred on allegations that both clubs were unfairly benefiting from state support via non-commercial deals with entities linked to the governments of Abu Dhabi and Qatar, respectively. Tebas argued that these arrangements distorted the market by allowing the two clubs to spend disproportionate amounts on transfers and wages. He alleged that such financial muscle, backed by non-market sources, gave them an unfair edge over traditional clubs operating within conventional revenue streams.
AdvertisementAFPTHE BIGGER PICTURE
Both clubs firmly denied the accusations and pointed to their audited financial statements as evidence of compliance. Club insiders also criticised Tebas’s motivations, attributing his actions to professional jealousy and a long-standing pattern of hostility toward clubs with state-backed ownership.
TELL ME MORE
Despite Tebas's fervent appeal, the European Commission has reportedly decided not to move forward with a formal investigation. According to the complaint did not present sufficient evidence to justify initiating proceedings under the EU’s foreign subsidies regulation.
A key issue, according to one source in Brussels, was the lack of a direct legal link between the clubs’ commercial revenue and the kind of foreign state aid prohibited under the regulation. While the involvement of state-related sponsors was acknowledged, the evidence did not meet the necessary threshold for triggering a broader legal inquiry. Officials are reportedly focused on cases that could serve as precedent-setting challenges across multiple industries. While football is undeniably high-profile, the submission from La Liga lacked the depth or scope required to elevate it into a landmark legal matter.
DID YOU KNOW?
Tensions between Tebas and City were already high before the complaint. In February, Tebas ignited further controversy by likening City’s financial structure to that of Enron, the notorious American energy company that collapsed in 2001 after one of the largest accounting scandals in corporate history.
